top of page

From Puzzling to Perfect: Screen, Score, and Succeed: Mastering the Art of Building Your Dream Team


Hiring the right candidate can be a daunting task, especially when you're faced with a mountain of resumes and cover letters to sift through. But fear not, my friend! In this blog, we'll take you through some out-of-the-box strategies to help you identify top talent and screen candidates efficiently. From creating customized skills assessments to conducting initial phone screens and reference checks, we've got you covered. So put on your thinking cap and get ready to discover some fresh and innovative ways to assess candidates like a pro!

  1. Conduct skills assessments: Use skills assessments to evaluate a candidate's technical skills and abilities. This can include tests, case studies, or challenges that are specific to the job requirements.

    1. Use real-world scenarios: Create assessments that mimic real-world scenarios and challenges that candidates are likely to face on the job. This can help assess a candidate's ability to solve problems, think critically, and apply their knowledge in a practical setting.

      1. Example: If you're hiring for a graphic designer, you can create an assessment that asks candidates to design a marketing campaign for a fictional product or service. This can help assess their ability to design for a specific target audience, create a cohesive brand identity, and develop effective marketing materials.

    2. Use online assessments: Use online assessments to evaluate a candidate's technical skills and abilities. This can include tests or challenges that are specific to the job requirements, such as coding challenges or proficiency tests.

      1. Example: If you're hiring for a software developer, you can use online coding challenges to assess their programming skills. For example, you can provide a coding challenge that asks the candidate to build a simple web application using a specific programming language.

    3. Use role-playing exercises: Use role-playing exercises to assess a candidate's soft skills, such as communication, conflict resolution, and customer service. This can help simulate situations that the candidate may encounter on the job and evaluate their ability to handle different scenarios.

      1. Example: If you're hiring for a customer service representative, you can conduct a role-playing exercise that simulates a customer service scenario. For example, you can ask the candidate to pretend they're handling a customer complaint and evaluate how they handle the situation.

    4. Use portfolio reviews: Ask candidates to provide a portfolio of their work to assess their skills and expertise. This can help evaluate a candidate's ability to perform specific tasks and demonstrate their knowledge and experience.

      1. Example: If you're hiring for a graphic designer, you can ask candidates to provide a portfolio of their work. You can review their portfolio to assess their design skills, creativity, and ability to work on a variety of projects.

    5. Conduct skills-based interviews: Conduct skills-based interviews to assess a candidate's ability to think on their feet and solve problems. This can include asking open-ended questions or providing a hypothetical scenario and asking the candidate to walk through how they would handle it.

      1. Example: If you're hiring for a marketing manager, you can conduct a skills-based interview that asks the candidate to develop a marketing plan for a new product. You can evaluate their ability to think strategically, develop effective marketing strategies, and communicate their ideas effectively.

    6. Use peer evaluations: Ask team members or industry experts to evaluate a candidate's skills and abilities. This can provide valuable insights and feedback from those who have experience in the same field.

      1. Example: If you're hiring for a web developer, you can ask industry experts to evaluate the candidate's coding skills. You can also ask current employees to evaluate the candidate's ability to work collaboratively, communicate effectively, and contribute to the team.

  2. Use behavioral-based interview questions: Use questions that are designed to assess a candidate's behavioral traits, such as their problem-solving skills, communication abilities, and work style. For example, "Tell me about a time when you had to resolve a conflict with a coworker. How did you handle the situation?"

  3. Check references: Conduct reference checks to validate a candidate's work history, accomplishments, and character. Ask for references from former supervisors or colleagues who have worked with the candidate before.

  4. Review online presence: Conduct a thorough review of a candidate's online presence, including social media profiles, personal blogs, and professional websites. This can provide insights into a candidate's personality, interests, and communication style.

  5. Perform background checks: Conduct background checks to verify a candidate's employment history, education, and criminal record. This can help ensure that the candidate meets the necessary qualifications for the job.

  6. Conduct team interviews: Include team members in the interview process to evaluate a candidate's fit with the team culture. This can help assess a candidate's teamwork and collaboration skills, and provide insights into how well they may work with the team.

Sifting through a large pool of candidates can be time-consuming and overwhelming. Here are some specific and actionable steps to help employers sift through hundreds of candidates efficiently:

  1. Set clear job requirements: Before you start reviewing applications, set clear job requirements that are specific to the role. This can help you quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements.

More specifically, to set clear job requirements:

  • Create a detailed job description: Create a job description that includes specific job duties, qualifications, and experience required for the role. Be as specific as possible, using industry-specific terminology and avoiding vague or general language.

  • Use specific and measurable criteria: Use specific and measurable criteria to evaluate candidates, such as years of experience, educational qualifications, or certifications. This can help you quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements.

  • Prioritize key skills and experience: Prioritize key skills and experience that are essential for the job. For example, if you're hiring a software engineer, you may prioritize experience with a specific programming language or experience working on specific types of projects.

Here's an example of setting clear job requirements for a software engineer role:

Job Description:

We are seeking a highly skilled software engineer with experience in Java and Python. The ideal candidate will have a Bachelor's or Master's degree in computer science or a related field and at least 3 years of experience in software development. The successful candidate will be responsible for designing, developing, and maintaining software applications that meet the needs of our clients.

Criteria for Evaluation:

  • Bachelor's or Master's degree in computer science or related field

  • At least 3 years of experience in software development

  • Experience with Java and Python

  • Strong analytical and problem-solving skills

  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills

By setting clear job requirements, you can quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements and focus on candidates who have the right qualifications and experience for the job. This can help make the screening process more efficient and effective.

  1. Use an applicant tracking system: Use an applicant tracking system (ATS) to manage applications and automate the screening process. An ATS can help you quickly filter out unqualified candidates and save time.

More specifically, to use an applicant tracking system:

  • Choose the right ATS: Choose an ATS that meets the needs of your organization and the specific job opening. Look for an ATS that can automate the screening process, filter out unqualified candidates, and manage the candidate pipeline.

  • Use keyword searches: Use keyword searches to quickly filter out unqualified candidates. This can include searching for specific job titles, education, or experience.

  • Customize the application process: Customize the application process to match the specific job opening. For example, if you're hiring for a graphic designer, you may ask candidates to submit a portfolio of their work.

  • Automate candidate communication: Use the ATS to automate candidate communication, such as sending automated emails to acknowledge receipt of their application or notifying candidates when they are no longer under consideration.

Here's an example of using an applicant tracking system:

The ABC Company is hiring for a marketing manager position. They use an ATS to manage the candidate pipeline and automate the screening process.

  • The marketing manager job posting is listed on the company's career site, and candidates are directed to apply through the ATS.

  • The ATS automatically filters out unqualified candidates based on specific job requirements, such as years of experience, education, or certifications.

  • The ABC Company uses keyword searches to quickly identify candidates who match the job requirements, such as candidates with experience in digital marketing or specific industries.

  • The ATS customizes the application process, asking candidates to submit a cover letter and portfolio of their work.

  • The ATS automates candidate communication, sending automated emails to acknowledge receipt of the application and notifying candidates when they are no longer under consideration.

By using an applicant tracking system, employers can efficiently manage applications, automate the screening process, and save time in the hiring process. This can help make the hiring process more efficient and effective.

  1. Use pre-screening questions: Use pre-screening questions to quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the job requirements. This can include questions about their experience, qualifications, and availability.

More specifically, to use pre-screening questions:

  • Determine key qualifications and experience: Determine the key qualifications and experience required for the job. Develop questions that directly relate to these qualifications and experience.

  • Ask open-ended questions: Ask open-ended questions that require candidates to provide detailed responses. This can help you assess their ability to communicate effectively and provide relevant information.

  • Use multiple-choice questions: Use multiple-choice questions to quickly evaluate candidates' knowledge and understanding of specific topics related to the job requirements.

  • Prioritize questions based on job requirements: Prioritize questions based on the job requirements and the level of importance. This can help you quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements.

Here's an example of using pre-screening questions:

The XYZ Company is hiring a sales representative. They use pre-screening questions to quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements.

  • The XYZ Company develops pre-screening questions that focus on the key qualifications and experience required for the job. This includes questions about the candidate's previous sales experience, knowledge of the industry, and ability to meet sales targets.

  • The pre-screening questions ask open-ended questions that require candidates to provide detailed responses. For example, "Describe your experience working in a sales role, and provide an example of a time when you exceeded your sales targets."

  • The XYZ Company uses multiple-choice questions to evaluate candidates' knowledge and understanding of specific topics related to the job requirements. For example, "Which of the following sales techniques have you used in the past? (a) cold calling (b) email marketing (c) social media advertising (d) all of the above."

  • The pre-screening questions are prioritized based on the job requirements and level of importance. Candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements are eliminated from consideration.

By using pre-screening questions, employers can quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements and focus on candidates who have the right qualifications and experience for the job. This can help make the screening process more efficient and effective.

  1. Develop a scoring system: Develop a scoring system to evaluate candidates based on specific criteria. This can help you compare candidates objectively and efficiently.

More specifically, to develop a scoring system:

  • Determine the criteria for evaluation: Determine the criteria that are most important for the job. This can include skills, experience, education, and personal attributes.

  • Assign a point value to each criterion: Assign a point value to each criterion based on its level of importance. This can help you objectively compare candidates based on their qualifications and experience.

  • Develop a rubric: Develop a rubric that outlines the scoring system and the criteria for evaluation. This can help ensure that everyone involved in the hiring process is on the same page and using the same criteria to evaluate candidates.

  • Standardize the scoring process: Standardize the scoring process to ensure that everyone is evaluating candidates consistently. This can include using a standardized evaluation form and providing clear instructions on how to evaluate candidates.

Here's an example of developing a scoring system:

The LMN Company is hiring for a project manager role. They develop a scoring system to evaluate candidates objectively and efficiently.

  • The LMN Company determines the criteria that are most important for the job, including project management experience, leadership skills, communication skills, and attention to detail.

  • The LMN Company assigns a point value to each criterion based on its level of importance. For example, project management experience may be worth 30 points, while attention to detail may be worth 10 points.

  • The LMN Company develops a rubric that outlines the scoring system and the criteria for evaluation. The rubric includes detailed descriptions of each criterion and the point value assigned to each criterion.

  • The LMN Company standardizes the scoring process by providing clear instructions on how to evaluate candidates and using a standardized evaluation form. This ensures that everyone is evaluating candidates consistently and using the same criteria to evaluate candidates.

By developing a scoring system, employers can compare candidates objectively and efficiently, ensuring that the most qualified candidate is selected for the job. This can help make the hiring process more efficient and effective.

  1. Conduct initial phone screens: Conduct initial phone screens with candidates to assess their communication skills, experience, and qualifications. This can help you quickly identify the most qualified candidates.

More specifically, to conduct initial phone screens:

  • Develop a script: Develop a script that outlines the key questions to ask during the phone screen. This can include questions about the candidate's experience, skills, and availability.

  • Prioritize questions: Prioritize the questions based on the job requirements and the level of importance. This can help you quickly eliminate candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements.

  • Evaluate communication skills: Evaluate the candidate's communication skills during the phone screen. This can include assessing their ability to articulate their thoughts clearly and concisely, as well as their tone and attitude.

  • Assess fit for the role: Assess the candidate's fit for the role, including their passion for the job, motivation, and ability to work collaboratively with others.

Here's an example of conducting initial phone screens:

The PQR Company is hiring a marketing coordinator. They conduct initial phone screens to narrow down the candidate pool and evaluate fit for the role.

  • The PQR Company develops a script that outlines the key questions to ask during the phone screen. This includes questions about the candidate's marketing experience, their understanding of the company's products and services, and their availability for the job.

  • The PQR Company prioritizes the questions based on the job requirements and the level of importance. For example, marketing experience is a top priority and candidates who do not meet the minimum requirements are eliminated from consideration.

  • During the phone screen, the PQR Company evaluates the candidate's communication skills, including their ability to articulate their thoughts clearly and concisely. They also assess the candidate's tone and attitude, looking for candidates who are positive, enthusiastic, and collaborative.

  • The PQR Company assesses the candidate's fit for the role, evaluating their passion for marketing and motivation to succeed in the job. They also look for candidates who are a good fit for the company's culture and can work collaboratively with others.

By conducting initial phone screens, employers can narrow down the candidate pool and evaluate fit for the role, making the screening process more efficient and effective. This can help ensure that the most qualified candidates are selected for the job.

  1. Use reference checks to validate qualifications: Use reference checks to validate a candidate's work history, accomplishments, and qualifications. This can help you ensure that the candidate meets the necessary requirements for the job.

More specifically, to conduct reference checks:

  • Request permission: Request permission from the candidate to conduct reference checks. This can include obtaining a signed consent form.

  • Develop a list of questions: Develop a list of questions to ask the candidate's references. This can include questions about their job performance, strengths, weaknesses, and interpersonal skills.

  • Verify employment history: Verify the candidate's employment history by confirming the dates of employment, job title, and job duties with their previous employers.

  • Evaluate personal attributes: Evaluate the candidate's personal attributes by asking questions about their work ethic, attitude, and ability to work well with others.

  • Document the results: Document the results of the reference checks and keep them on file for future reference.

Here's an example of conducting reference checks:

The ABC Company is hiring a project manager. They conduct reference checks to verify the candidate's employment history, job performance, and personal attributes.

  • The ABC Company requests permission from the candidate to conduct reference checks and obtains a signed consent form.

  • The ABC Company develops a list of questions to ask the candidate's references, including questions about their ability to manage projects, their communication skills, and their ability to work well with others. Some question ideas:

    • Can you verify the dates of employment and job title of the candidate?

    • What were the candidate's main job responsibilities and duties?

    • Can you provide specific examples of the candidate's work performance or achievements in their previous role?

    • How would you describe the candidate's work style and communication skills?

    • Can you comment on the candidate's ability to work well in a team or independently?

    • Did the candidate meet expectations in their previous role? If not, what were the areas they struggled in?

    • Were there any performance or behavior issues that arose during the candidate's employment? If so, how were they addressed?

    • Would you hire the candidate again in the future? Why or why not?

    • Can you provide any additional information about the candidate's personal attributes or character?

    • Is there anything else that you think we should know about the candidate?

These questions can help you gain valuable insights into the candidate's job performance, personal attributes, and overall fit for the role. It's important to ask open-ended questions and encourage the reference to provide detailed responses. Additionally, it's a good idea to tailor the questions to the specific job requirements and the candidate's background.

  • The ABC Company documents the results of the reference checks and keeps them on file for future reference.

By conducting reference checks, employers can verify a candidate's employment history, job performance, and personal attributes, ensuring that the most qualified candidate is selected for the job. This can help make the screening process more thorough and effective.


Screening and assessing candidates doesn't have to be a tedious and time-consuming process. By using some of the innovative strategies we've covered in this blog, you can streamline your hiring process and identify top talent more efficiently. Whether it's creating customized skills assessments, conducting initial phone screens, or conducting reference checks, there are plenty of ways to identify the most qualified candidates for your job opening.


So, put these strategies into practice, stay positive, and get ready to find your next rockstar employee! Remember, when you take the time to screen and assess candidates effectively, you're not just making a smart business decision, you're also investing in the success of your company and your team.


Commentaires


bottom of page